Monday, April 6, 2009

Book Review: The Rose Without A Thorn

This novel of Katherine Howard, the fifth of Henry VIII’s six wives, was a very enjoyable and clarifying historical read. To begin with, let’s agree that Katherine was never given a fair chance in comparison to the King’s other wives. Katherine was not as extravagant, well-known, or amazingly beautiful as some of the more renowned ones were. She was extremely young to be a bride; a child in fact. So, this in itself puts her in a category of her own.

The author brilliantly exposes this fact by writing in the first person, so that we are never to forget the fact that she was merely a child. Reading it from this point of view makes the history so much more understandable. It is difficult to be judgmental towards Katherine in any way when you read the story through her perspective.

Katherine Howard’s life is pretty simple up until she moves into the Royal Court; where, she is ultimately set-up for her demise. The events in her life unfold like a cruel domino effect, led by the deceptions and scheming of others leading Katherine to her tragic end. Her innocence, kindness, curiosity, and acts without malice, rendered her character simply endearing. Plaidy captures the essence of this Child-Belle enraptured in a world of delusion, schemes and intrigues. The game was too quick and too fierce for her to endure. Inevitably, this young girl’s innocent and hopeful nature could never survive in the vulturous world of Henry VIII.

The Rose Without a Thorn is a quick read that moves you from one scene to the next in smooth and inviting transition. The passages are moving and although I often felt exasperated by some of Katherine’s decisions and motives, I felt I understood this character precisely because of her circumstances. The build up to the tragedy is difficult and ultimately heartbreaking. Excellent read.


  1. I really loved this novel about Katherine! And you are so right - this poor girl never had a chance! She really had no one to turn to, except the bad influences at her grandmother's home - no one to guide her or care for her - she was lost and then thrown to the wolves at court. And she, still only a sad!

  2. This is by far my favorite Plaidy novel so far - like you said - the denouement of the tragedy is so well done. I read it in one sitting on a hot summer day and actually felt cold during the last 50 pages of the book.

  3. Hi Amy- What a sad, sad story- so true. and that grandmother ugh!

    Hi Judy- I love this one too. And so much tension and sadness right up until the end.

  4. I read this book a while ago.She was used by her ambitious family, a terrible ending.

  5. This is the 2nd Plaidy novel I read and I had the same thoughts that you do on it.

    You won't get that vibe from Philippa Gregory's novel The Boleyn Inheritance. Plaidy just has a way of showing people's good and bad sides.

  6. Great delivery. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the good

    my blog post - viagra generique avis

  7. Hello, i feel that i saw you visited my weblog so i got here to return the favor?
    .I am attempting to to find issues to improve my site!I guess its adequate to make use of a few of your concepts!


    Also visit my homepage :: viagra generique acheter

  8. Asking questions are really pleasant thing if you
    are not understanding something fully, except this paragraph provides nice understanding yet.

    my page :: sell house property quickly